Who is popular today?

Which “Pretty Little Liars” star would make the best babysitter? Shay Mitchell — “You” actress and mom to 8-month-old Atlas — sat down with Page Six for a game of “Most Likely.” From Ashley Benson to Troian Bellisario, find out which former co-star would excel at gift-giving, babysitting, making TikToks and more.   Subscribe to...